Institute at Brown for Environment and Society

Brown Climate Study Named Finalist for PNAS Cozzarelli Prize

Professor Dov Sax and fellow researchers received recognition for their IBES-supported study challenging traditional forecasting methods for the impacts of climate change on species.

Dov Sax
Dov Sax, an IBES and EEOB professor and co-author of the study

A recent study from IBES and the Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Organismal Biology (EEOB) at Brown was named a finalist for the 2024 PNAS Cozzarelli Prize this month. It was one of just 12 papers, of more than 3,200 papers published across all fields of science by the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), recognized for its scientific excellence and originality. 

The study, “A species’ response to spatial climatic variation does not predict its response to climate change,” challenges a fundamental assumption used to predict how species will respond to climate shifts. Many climate models assume that the way a species currently varies across its geographic range can be used to project how its populations will respond to future climate change. However, by analyzing climate records and tree-ring growth data from 23 populations of ponderosa pine trees across the western U.S., the team found that these traditional forecasting methods not only miscalculate the magnitude of expected change but often predict the wrong direction of change — suggesting increased growth where declines actually occur. 

Their findings reveal that species with broad geographic range, once thought to be relatively climate-resilient, may be at far greater risk from climate change than previously recognized. This discovery represents a major shift in ecological forecasting and underscores the need for more sophisticated, empirically driven approaches to modeling the impacts of climate change. By challenging long-held assumptions, these insights provide a new framework for understanding species’ vulnerability in a rapidly changing climate.

The study was co-authored by Dov Sax, Brown professor of environment and society & ecology, evolution, and organismal biology; Daniel L. Perret, a former IBES graduate affiliate and current postdoctoral research fellow with the USDA Forest Service; and Margaret. E. K. Evans, an associate professor of dendrochronology at the University of Arizona. 

This study was bolstered by an IBES Research, Training, and Travel (RTT) award, which provided critical support for fieldwork, conferences, and collaboration. PNAS’s recognition of this work highlights the importance of investing in rigorous, data-driven science, and IBES is proud to support researchers tackling some of the most pressing environmental challenges of our time.